2008-01-18 Michal Kubicki
Listen to the report >>

New books on afterwar Polish-Jewish relations provoke heated debate in Poland

Not for the first time in recent memory there’s controversy in Poland on a World War II issue. Two books on Polish-Jewish relations after the war have just been published, both by Polish-born historians living in the United States. Michal Kubicki of Polish Radio’s External Service looks at why the books are set to provoke heated debate on one of the most complex chapters in Poland’s modern history.

The books in question are ‘Fear. Anti-Semitism in Poland after Auschwitz’ by Jan Tomasz Gross, former professor at Princeton University, and ‘After the Holocaust. Polish-Jewish Conflict in the Wake of World War II’ by Marek Jan Chodakiewicz, Dean at the Institute of World Politics in Washington.

Gross is far better known to the Polish public. Several years ago his ‘Neighbours’, a book about the 1941 massacre of Jews by the Polish inhabitants of Jedwabne, provoked a debate which led to a re-appraisal of history written under Poland’s communist regime. It showed that the image of Poles being only the heroes and martyrs of the war was not true. Gross’s new book ‘Fear’ focuses on the 1946 Kielce pogrom in which 40 Jews were killed.

Jan GrossJan Gross
‘A Jew [in post-war Poland] was looked upon as a threat, for various reasons. He could claim the right to someone’s property. He also brought back the memories of various terrible things and crimes in which many people were involved during the occupation. Anti-Semitic actions enjoyed acceptance of broad sections of Polish society. Those responsible for them have not been condemned by the local communities until today.’

In ‘Fear’ Gross writes about what he describes as Polish ‘society’s violently expressed desire to render the country free of Jews’. He declared that he wanted his book to act as a ‘shock therapy’. Professor Chodakiewicz says that a historian’s goal should rather be to reconstruct the truth about the events under study. His own extensive research led him to conclude that most Jews who were killed in post-war Poland were not the victims of anti-Semitism. He stresses that Polish-Jewish relations in the 1940s should be examined in the context of the Soviet-imposed communist dictatorship.

‘Whoever has been despoiled by the Nazis and the communists should have his or her property restored. That goes both for the Christians and the Jews. That didn’t happen because of the communist hostility towards private property. Therefore there were conflicts over property which only the communists could have solved. Also the communists entirely destroyed the machinery of the Polish state. When the communists pushed the Nazis out of Poland they started shooting, arresting and deporting functionaries of free Poland. That also means the police and the judiciary of the underground. That means that there was no law and order. When there’s no law and order banditry is rampant’.

The debate on the two books have only just started in the Polish media and the academic circles. For historian Marcin Zaremba of Warsaw University, Gross’s ‘Fear’ is a very important publication.

Marek Jan ChodakiewiczMarek Jan Chodakiewicz
‘I agree with his argument that Poles had their share in the Holocaust and that Polish peasants took part in the murder of Jews in Jedwabne, Radziłów, the regions of Łomża, Zamość and Kielce. I agree that anti-Semitism was a kind of cultural code which Poles used at that time, and that Jews were not responsible for the introduction of communist rule in Poland.’

Many Polish historians recognize the positive aspects of Gross’s book but argue that the author’s strong language makes serious debate extremely difficult. Professor Paweł Machcewicz took Gross to task for claiming that during the war Poles participated in the Holocaust and after the war they finished ethnic cleansing against Jews. According to Machcewicz such a view is unjustified.

The debate on Polish-Jewish relations which followed the publication of Gross’s ‘Neighbours’ demonstrated the Polish nation’s readiness to confront some of the most difficult facts in its history. According to political analyst Mariusz Ziomecki Poles shouldn’t be wasting time on trying to diminish their discomfort.

‘It’s much better to simply accept co-responsibility and accept the news that there were some heroic attitudes but also some acts of exploitation of the victims. That’s it. This is part of the luggage that we have to carry.’

Polish prosecutors launched a probe against Gross under a section of a criminal code providing for a three years’ prison term for anyone ‘publicly accusing the Polish nation of participating in, organizing or being responsible for Nazi or Communist crimes’. Both the admirers and critics of the book agree that this is a wrong decision. A prominent Polish bishop said: ‘books should be read and discussed, and those of poor quality – simply ignored.’

Listen to the report:

Tags

poland, racism, society

Share

digg
del.icio.us
facebook
newsvine

Listen

Real Audio

Download

MP3

Podcast

Subscribe

Also in this issue

Spain’s abortion law is coming under close scrutiny where the government says it is prepared to consider changing the legislation if it can achieve a wide political and social consensus. The announcement follows women from a feminist collective reporting themselves to police for illegal abortions, in order to draw attention to the what they see as the failings of the law. Private abortion clinics have also been on a week long strike to protest against a law they say doesn’t protect medical practitioners or the woman who have abortions. The strike was a response to a recent series of police raids on abortion clinics accused of carrying out illegal terminations. From Madrid, Deutsche Welle’s Danny Wood reports… >>>

Staying with the issue of national identity now, but from a rather different angle... The Second World War is high on the agenda again in Germany. But this time not because of German war crimes, but instead because of German war victims: the millions of Germans that were expelled from territories the country lost to Poland and Russia. The German government wants to erect a "visible sign", or a permanent exhibition, describing their fate. The proposal has sparked a fierce debate with neighboring Poland. Radio Netherlands Worldwide correspondent Laurens Boven spoke with Hertha Mahlow, an elderly woman from Berlin who experienced the expulsion as a young woman. >>>

Teenagers are vearing T-Shirts similar to this oneWhile Poland and Germany try to get to grips with their pasts, the United States seems intent on creating its own present-day controversy. The concept of rendition flights has appeared in our headlines in the last couple of years – terror suspects flown secretly, through different countries’ airspaces and interrogated in secret locations. Human Rights groups have complained bitterly that the practice is illegal on a number of levels. Sweden has produced its own negative headlines in relation to the alleged CIA-flights … but as Radio Sweden's Bill Schiller now reports there are some Swedish teenagers currently trying to draw attention to the problem - in their very own way. >>>

After becoming the first French president to divorce during his time in office, Nicholas Sarkozy looks set to become the first to marry as well. He certainly is keen to keep himself busy. This week he described his relationship with Carla Bruni as ”serious” and hinted that a wedding, perhaps in secret, could be expected soon. Our Paris correspondent John Laurenson says if Carla Bruni becomes Carla Sarkozy it would revolutionise the role of France’s first lady and mark a victory for a certain sort of women’s lib’. >>>

Maltese-registered tanker Erika sinked Dec. 13, 1999 - photography from a French Navy planeWe stay in France for some more serious news: last Wednesday The French oil company Total was ordered to pay it's a share of nearly 200 million in damages for a 1999 oil spill off the northwest coast of France. The Erika oil tanker broke in half in December of 1999, spilling almost 20-thousand tons of crude oil into the sea—which killed hundreds of thousands of birds along 400 kilometers of coastline. Radio France International's Sarah Elzas was at the courtroom in Paris for the verdict. >>>

Brussels Briefing

Quentin Dickenson

Brussels - Townhallwe turn our attention to Brussels where our correspondent Quentin Dickenson told me a short while ago what our European policymakers have been up to in our names this week… >>>

And before we sign off: do take part in this months quiz. This month, we're looking for the name of a French composer whose birth 100 years ago is being celebrated in 2008. "He was organist in the church 'La Trinite' in Paris. He composed a lot of pieces, too, for organ. And I think it's the more important composers in terms of organ in the 20th century". So who is this man? We already know he's a composer who had synethesia- a condition where a person literally hears colors. He's also a very religious man. If you know the answer, send it to contact at networkeurope dot org. Include your name and where you listen to Network Europe. >>>

Latest Programme
The Programme About Us
Programme Archive RSS and Podcasting
Contact Us
PARTNER STATIONS
Deutsche Welle Deutsche Welle Polish Radio External Service Polish Radio External Service Radio Bulgaria Radio Bulgaria Radio France International Radio France International Radio Netherlands Radio Netherlands Worldwide Radio Prague Radio Prague Radio Romania International Radio Romania International Radio Slovakia International Radio Slovakia International Radio Slovenia International Radio Slovenia International Radio Sweden Radio Sweden