2007-11-30 Sarah Elzas
Listen to the report >>

Who predicted a riot?

Riot police face young residents of Villiers-le-Bel, a northern Paris suburb, while a garbage truck burns in the background, during clashes late MondayRiot police face young residents of Villiers-le-Bel, a northern Paris suburb, while a garbage truck burns in the background, during clashes late Monday
This fall the French president Nicolas Sarkozy has been facing tests of his policies—from strikes against his pension reforms, to protests against his education changes---now he's facing a challenge to his urban policies.

Dozens of police officers were injured Monday and Tuesday evening in a northern Paris suburb when angry young people threw stones, Molotov cocktails and even shot at them with hunting guns.

They event that set off the violence was the death on Sunday of two teenaged boys whose mini-motorcycle collided with a police car.

The violence had pretty much calmed down by Wednesday- and was mainly contained to the paris region- The whole situation has rasied the spectre of massive riots 2 years ago throughout the country— RFI's Sarah Elzas has been following the story and the reactions around it.

So, what happened here? Why did this spiral into violence?

Residents walk past a car that was burnt overnight during clashes between youths and police in Villiers-le-Bel, a northern Paris suburb, TuesdayResidents walk past a car that was burnt overnight during clashes between youths and police in Villiers-le-Bel, a northern Paris suburb, Tuesday
Sarah: Well, it's clear by the intensity of the reactions to these tow kinds deaths that this is a deep problem- of resentment to the police, and perhaps even bigger than that.

There is an official investigation inot what actually happened Sunday night- But it's not really about what actually happened- but about the perception of what happened.

People are angry that the police didn't do more to investigate right away- and at this point relations are so bad between police and the neighbourhood, that even if the truth comes out- no one will believe it

Our reporter Brent Gregston went out to Villiers le Bel and met a retired police officer who sums it up:

police officer: "What's clear is that there are neighbourhoods where the police has trouble entering- And systematically when there's an incident, it's seen as the fault of the police- So even if the conclusion here is that the police didn't do anything- that will always been contested by the young people and their families"

So-why is the relationship so bad? There were riots in 2005, and supposedly the result was that problems were going to be fixed?

Sarah: Well, exactly-There were promises- and some money has been spent on these poor suburbs and neighbourhoods-- but what is probably needed is a systematic overhaul- which hasn't been done

The minister in charge of urban affairs is supposed to provide recommendations in January of how to reform the suburbs- But the problem stretches farther than housing projects- You've got systemic discrimination in employment—in a job market with really high unemployment.

This doesn't necessarily directly affect the teenagers who are directly involved in this violence—but it does affect the mood around them, and foments the disappointment and anger

What has President Sarkozy's reaction been?

French President Nicolas Sarkozy, second right, and Interior Minister Michele Alliot-Marie, right, visit an unidentified police officer injured during clashes with riotersFrench President Nicolas Sarkozy, second right, and Interior Minister Michele Alliot-Marie, right, visit an unidentified police officer injured during clashes with rioters
In a speech to a group of police officers on Thursday he stressed that these riots had nothing to do with a systemic problem- but rather were the result of a band of hooligans.

When he went to visit some of the injured police officers on Wednesday, he insisted that those responsible be brought to justice:

President Sarkozy: "Those who take the responsibility of shooting at public servants will find themselves in court- This has a name: it's called "attempted murder". We'll find the shooters—we'll spend what we need to do that, Those who took on this responsibility will have to explain themselves to this country's justice system."

So what you see here is Sarkozy refusing to aknowledge a lot of the anger and frustration that gave rise to this outpouring of violence.

One thing to remember- Sarkozy got elected partly because of his attitude towards the 2005 riots—as interior minister before and during those riots, he gained a reputation of a tough-on delinquience, zero-tolerance stance

He has a balancing act to do now- between calming these violent uprisings- but also appeasing the middle class of france, which doesn't know much about the problems that gave rise to the anger-

In fact, he was elected with a mandate to reform the economy, to increase jobs and reduce unemployment- And on some level, if he does manage to do that, it may solve many of these problems-

A large part of the anger is people feel discriminated against for jobs- and angry that they aren't integrated- if there were more jobs, that might gloss over the proble

Listen to the report:


france, paris, riots




Real Audio





Also in this issue

Galileo, not doing the fandango

Richard Walker and Vanessa Mock

Launch of the first Galileo In-Orbit Validation Element test satellite - GIOVE-AIn case you haven’t come across the GPS sat-nav system yet, it’s a system of satellites that pinpoint your car and then beam information to the the voice under your dashboard, which in turn tells you verbally to turn right, left or go straight ahead. The EU’s ‘Galileo’ project is supposed to rival America’s GPS satellite navigation system. But being the EU there has been drawn out wrangling about how the project will be funded, stalling progress for months. Until now. >>>

Remember the gulag

Alexander Hirschfelder

Gulag prisoners building BelomorkanalThe Swedish government’s sparked a bad tempered debate this week over how schools should deal with the era of communist history in Europe and Russia. Sweden’s Education Minister wants to make classes on communism and the Soviet regime’s crimes obligatory. Some opponents say that by setting a rigid history syllabus for schools is itself quite authoritarian. Stalin would approve perhaps, if the subject was something other than his reviled gulags. >>>

Courting attention in Holland

John Tyler and Richard Walker

Geert WildersOne of the Netherlsnds’ most controversial politicians, Geert Wilders, has thrust himself back into the spotlight this week. You may have heard of Mr Wilders, journalists usually put the word “controversial” in front of his name. He’s a parliamentarian known as an Islam-basher and it’s now emerged he is making a film denouncing Islam and arguing for the Koran to be banned. Immediately, parallels are being drawn with the film “Submission”, made by murdered Dutch film-maker Theo van Gogh and writer Ayan Hirsi-Ali. That film pushed the issue of Moslem integration in Holland up the political agenda, especially after Van Gogh’s murder by an Islamic extremist. >>>

Blowin’ in the wind

Jerome Socolovsky

Lines of cocaine on a mirrorIt’ll be a white Christmas for more European party-goers than ever before this year. Cocaine abuse is on the rise across Europe, and particularly in Spain. So far in 2007, Spanish police have intercepted five shipments each holding over 3 tonnes of the drug. With such high supply, prices have dropped and the Iberian peninsular is awash with the narcotic that keeps you up all night. DW’s Jerome Socolovsky reports from Madrid's Barajas airport, one of the key entry points for smugglers from Latin America. >>>

The new Polish government

Michal Kubicki

Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, right, waves after his speech in the parliament presenting the new government's programSix weeks after Poles voted the conservative Law and Justice party out of office, Poland's new government is in place, with Prime Minister Donald Tusk at the helm. So what does the Polish man-in-the-street expect from the new leadership? And what does the new cabinet stand for? Michal Kubicki of Polish Radio's External Service reports. >>>

Latest Programme
The Programme About Us
Programme Archive RSS and Podcasting
Contact Us
Deutsche Welle Deutsche Welle Polish Radio External Service Polish Radio External Service Radio Bulgaria Radio Bulgaria Radio France International Radio France International Radio Netherlands Radio Netherlands Worldwide Radio Prague Radio Prague Radio Romania International Radio Romania International Radio Slovakia International Radio Slovakia International Radio Slovenia International Radio Slovenia International Radio Sweden Radio Sweden